The Executive Review
Jeff Osterfeld
Franchise Owner Profile

Jeff Osterfeld

Founder & CEO · Penn Station Sandwiches · Cincinnati, Ohio
Penn Station Sandwiches ↗
No. 52 on Top 100 Franchise Owners 2026 · Brand Owner · See the full list →

Jeff Osterfeld turned a cheesesteak he added to his Dayton Mall deli into Penn Station, which he opened in downtown Cincinnati in 1985 and has franchised since 1988 to more than 300 restaurants.

Share on LinkedIn

A deli in the Dayton Mall

In 1983 Jeff Osterfeld owned and ran Jeffrey's Delicatessen in the Dayton Mall in Dayton, Ohio. The company says that is where his "ownership mentality" took shape, as he saw how his presence in the store affected food quality, customer service and sales. After a trip to Philadelphia, he added his own version of the cheesesteak to the deli's menu, and it quickly became a hit.[1]

He opened the first Penn Station in downtown Cincinnati in 1985. The original menu had four sandwiches, led by the grilled cheesesteak, along with fresh-cut fries and hand-squeezed lemonade, all made in front of customers.[1]

Franchising since 1988

Osterfeld turned the concept into a franchise in 1988. Nearly all locations are franchised, and when the chain marked its 30th anniversary in 2015 it had almost 300 restaurants in 15 states. Craig Dunaway, who became president in 1999 when the chain had 63 stores, said then that Osterfeld "created the model for success in 1985."[1][2]

In 2025, its 40th anniversary year, Penn Station opened four restaurants, sold 15 franchise units, entered two new markets and launched the Penn Station Rewards loyalty program. It ended the year with more than 320 locations and was ranked No. 459 on the Entrepreneur Franchise 500 and No. 171 on the Nation's Restaurant News Technomic Top 500, and was inducted into QSR Magazine's Best Franchise Deals Hall of Fame.[3]

Penn Station Sandwiches

In July 2026 the company renamed itself Penn Station Sandwiches, with a new identity and a menu that added 9-grain sandwiches, wraps and bowls while keeping its subs, fries and lemonade. Lance Vaught is the company's president. The chain's core states are Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky and Pennsylvania, and it is expanding in North Carolina, South Carolina and Michigan, including a move into Myrtle Beach led by Charlotte-based franchisees.[4]

Giving back and golf

Penn Station's annual Deals for Down Syndrome campaign sells coupon booklets and matches every dollar raised for local Down syndrome associations. In September 2025 the company presented $330,676 to the Down Syndrome Association of Greater Cincinnati, and total giving has passed $2 million. "Surpassing $2 million in support is something we're incredibly proud of," Osterfeld said in 2026.[3][5]

Outside the restaurant business, Osterfeld is the designer and owner of The Golf Club at Stonelick Hills in Ohio.[6]

On the Top 100 Franchise Owners

Jeff Osterfeld is No. 52 on The Executive Review's Top 100 Franchise Owners 2026. The ranking is editorial and independent; placement is never sold. View the full list.

Share on LinkedIn
More from the Top 100 Franchise Owners

See all 100 franchise owners → · Top 100 Private Growth Executives (monthly C-suite rankings) →